The “Only Murders in the Building” Diner is Actually on the Upper East Side
Named The Pickle Diner on the show, here’s where to find the blue diner on Only Murders in the Building.
Have you seen the Hulu series Only Murders in the Building? No spoilers, I promise, but I love this show—especially the Canadian-American treasure Martin Short. In season two of the series, the cast spends a lot of time in The Pickle Diner, meant to be located on the UWS. The restaurant is actually called The Mansion Restaurant and Eatery and sits on the corner of York and 86th Street; and according to the diner’s website, The Mansion has been around since 1945.
Like a lot of New Yorkers, we have our favorite diner. When the New Amity diner on Madison Ave. recently closed, we decided to try The Mansion, and it was fantastic. The restaurant is close to our apt (a must, right?) and the food is really good and the service is so kind and efficient. You may not always see celebs but it’s a very solid choice for your go-to neighborhood diner.
The Mansion Diner is located at: 1634 York Ave, New York, NY 10028